The Best Beef Wellington in Milwaukee and Suburbs

Craving that elegant pastry-wrapped filet? Greater Milwaukee offers nearly a dozen dining destinations serving Beef Wellington—from classic supper clubs with cognac sauces to lakeside fine dining with black truffle preparations. The Packing House in Milwaukee stands as the region's most reliable everyday option at $59.99, while The Commodore in Hartland delivers the most luxurious experience at $150-180 for two.

Beef Wellington represents the pinnacle of celebratory dining: a perfectly seared filet mignon wrapped in savory mushroom duxelles, encased in golden puff pastry, and typically served with rich wine or cognac sauce. This dish originated in early 19th-century England, named for the Duke of Wellington, and has become a benchmark for special-occasion cooking. Finding it on a restaurant menu signals serious culinary ambition—making your hunt worthwhile for memorable family celebrations, anniversaries, or simply an extraordinary Tuesday.

This guide covers every confirmed Beef Wellington location across greater Milwaukee, organized by region so you can plan your culinary adventure.

Milwaukee

The Packing House ★ Editor's Pick

This family-owned Milwaukee institution has served their signature Beef Wellington for over 50 years, earning consistent recognition as "the best Beef Wellington in Wisconsin" from multiple sources including OnMilwaukee and Experience Wisconsin.

Detail Information Address 900 E. Layton Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53207 Phone (414) 483-5054 Website packinghousemke.com Hours Tue 11am-8pm, Wed-Thu 11am-9pm, Fri 11am-10pm, Sat 3:30pm-10pm, Sun 4pm-8pm, Closed Monday Price $59.99 (7oz portion)

How it's prepared: Filet mignon with roasted mushrooms and scallions encased in a tender pastry shell, served with cognac sauce, fresh vegetables, and choice of side dish (rice pilaf, baked potato, mashed potatoes, French fries, or pasta). Every order includes hot bread and butter plus house salad or soup du jour.

Important ordering note: The Wellington is prepared medium only—essential to know before ordering.

Family-friendly features: The Packing House operates as a scratch kitchen where everything from dressings to breadings is made in-house. Their legendary Friday Fish Fry offers a drive-through option from 3-9pm—perfect for busy families. The dining room accommodates celebrations comfortably, and their award-winning patio (Mayor's Design Award winner) provides seasonal outdoor seating. Live music plays Wednesday evenings and Friday-Saturday nights.

Menu highlights for families: The Grand Steer Filet ($75.99) won Best of Show at the Wisconsin State Fair, as did their Steak au Poivre ($64.99). Prime Rib appears Wednesday, Saturday, and Sunday only. Their BBQ Pork Back Ribs and Twin Maine Lobster Tails round out the celebration-worthy options.

Reservations: Strongly recommended, especially weekends. Call (414) 483-5054. Holiday reservations required—they're open Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, New Year's Eve (with live music), and New Year's Day.

Dream Dance Steakhouse

Located inside Potawatomi Casino Hotel, this recently renovated fine-dining destination occasionally features Beef Wellington as a special.

Detail Information Address 1721 W Canal Street, Milwaukee, WI 53233 Phone (414) 847-7883 Website potawatomi.com/restaurants/dream-dance-steakhouse Hours Wed-Thu-Sun 5pm-10pm, Fri-Sat 5pm-11pm, Closed Mon-Tue Price Range $$$$ (Fine dining)

Beef Wellington availability: Listed on Yelp under Beef Wellington category—call to confirm current availability as this appears to be a rotating special rather than permanent menu item.

Family-friendly features: The $1.8 million renovation created sophisticated but comfortable spaces. Complimentary validated valet parking removes parking stress. The private Vinter Room seats 14 for family celebrations. Prime beef sourced from Allen Brothers ensures quality, and their 400+ wine selection accommodates every palate.

Reservations: Recommended; book online or call.

Red Lion Pub

This British pub created an innovative Beef Wellington Sandwich as a special—a more casual, affordable way to experience the flavors.

Detail Information Address 1850 N Water Street, Milwaukee, WI 53202 Phone (414) 431-9009 Website redlionpubmke.com Hours Mon-Wed 4pm-12am, Thu 11am-12am, Fri 11am-1am, Sat 9am-1am, Sun 9am-12am Price Range $$ (Casual dining)

Family-friendly features: British pub atmosphere with soccer viewing, happy hour 4-6pm, plus classic scotch eggs and fish and chips for kids who want something familiar. Delivery available via Uber Eats for families preferring takeout.

Lake Country delivers fine dining destinations

The communities surrounding Pewaukee Lake and Lake Nagawicka offer two of the region's most distinguished Wellington experiences.

The Commodore — A Bartolotta Restaurant ★ Most Upscale

This lakeside gem from the James Beard Award-winning Bartolotta Restaurant Group serves what may be the region's most refined Beef Wellington preparation.

Detail Information Address 1807 Nagawicka Road, Hartland, WI 53029 Phone (262) 563-8070 Website bartolottas.com/commodore Hours Wed-Sun 5pm-9pm; Sunday Brunch 10am-2pm Price $150-180 for two (serves 2 persons)

How it's prepared: A 16-ounce Prime, barrel-cut filet baked in puff pastry with mushroom duxelles and Black Truffle-Périgourdine Sauce, served with scalloped potatoes and creamed spinach. Corporate Executive Chef Aaron Bickham painstakingly researched the dish's history—it honors Sir Arthur Wellesley, First Duke of Wellington, celebrating his 1815 Battle of Waterloo victory.

Family-friendly features: The historic 1902 property (former Seven Seas restaurant) offers lakeside views of Lake Nagawicka that captivate children and adults alike. Private dining rooms (Margo's and Pepper's) accommodate family celebrations away from the main dining room. Business casual dress code keeps the atmosphere elevated but not intimidating. Window and patio seating can be requested when booking.

Menu highlights for families: Oysters Rockefeller ($24), Beverly's Curried Shrimp & Crab Bisque ($12), and Saturday-only Prime Rib with Yorkshire Pudding ($79) offer celebratory alternatives. Daily specials include Veal Marsala (Tuesday), Short Rib Pot Roast (Wednesday), and Beef Stroganoff (Thursday).

Reservations: Essential, especially for Wellington. Book via OpenTable. The restaurant holds 4.5 stars across 608+ reviews.

Red Circle Inn ★ Best for Special Events

Wisconsin's oldest restaurant (established 1848) offers both regular-menu Wellington and extraordinary multi-course Wellington dinner events.

Detail Information Address N44 W33013 Watertown Plank Road, Nashotah, WI 53058 Phone (262) 367-4883 Website redcircleinn.com Hours Mon-Thu 4:30pm-9pm, Fri-Sat 4:30pm-10pm, Sun 3pm-8pm

Regular menu preparation: Classic Beef Wellington with roasted shiitake, cremini, and maitake mushrooms, roasted garlic broccolini, and port wine sauce.

Special Beef Wellington Dinner Events: At $125 plus tax and gratuity, these ticketed multi-course experiences in the Provimi Room include:

• Reception with Prosecco or Old Fashioned, hors d'oeuvres (crispy prime rib bites, salmon croquettes, bacon-wrapped dates)

• First Course: Frisée & Arugula Salad

• Second Course (choice of three): Classic Beef Wellington, Salmon Wellington, or Garden Wellington (vegetarian)—each paired with wine

• Third Course: Chocolate Caramel Mousse paired with Port Wine or Manhattan

Family-friendly features: The historic building features vintage photographs, tin ceilings, exposed wood beams, and the original fireplace—history lessons in ambiance form. A traditional relish tray starts every meal, giving kids something to nibble while waiting. Wisconsin Brandy Old Fashioned cocktails made with Wollersheim Brandy showcase local craftsmanship, while Pink Squirrel and Grasshopper ice cream drinks appeal to dessert lovers of all ages.

Reservations: Strongly recommended via OpenTable (4.5 stars, 1,541+ reviews). Special Wellington dinner events require advance ticket purchase through SimpleTix—check their website for upcoming dates.

Thunder Bay Grille

This casual-upscale spot offers Wellington on Fridays according to customer reviews.

Detail Information Address N14 W24130 Tower Place, Pewaukee, WI 53072 Phone (262) 523-4244 Website thunderbaygrille.com/pewaukee Hours Typically 11am-9pm/10pm Price Range $$ (Mid-range)

Beef Wellington availability: Reported available on Fridays—call to confirm. Their Certified Angus Beef is aged 28-35 days.

Family-friendly features: Rustic décor with cozy fireplaces creates warmth for families. Kid-friendly menu options, patio seating, salad bar, and brunch buffet make this accessible for various ages and appetites. Private event capabilities accommodate larger family celebrations.

Southern suburbs offer supper club charm

Joey Gerard's — A Bartolotta Supper Club

Another gem from the Bartolotta group, this 1940s/50s Hollywood-glamour supper club in historic Greendale village serves Wellington among its signature items.

Detail Information Address 5601 Broad Street, Greendale, WI 53129 Phone (414) 858-1900 Website bartolottas.com/joey-gerards Hours Tue-Thu 11am-9pm, Fri 11am-10pm, Sat 3:30pm-10pm, Sun 4pm-8pm, Closed Monday Price Range $$$ (Upscale casual)

Beef Wellington availability: Listed on Yelp and Foursquare ("Love the Wellington!")—call ahead to confirm current availability as it may rotate as a special.

How it's prepared: The restaurant uses the Midwest's first Josper charcoal oven for their steaks, indicating serious culinary commitment to preparation technique.

Family-friendly features: Dark leather booths provide privacy for families. The famous "Montague" moose head above the fireplace fascinates children. Lazy Susans on tables and relish trays at every setting give kids engagement points. Their Friday Fish Fry includes a drive-through option from 3-9pm—ideal for families wanting quality without the full sit-down experience. Curbside pickup also available. Private rooms (Reiman Room, Skylight Room) accommodate celebrations.

Menu highlights for families: Prime Rib (Wednesday, Saturday, Sunday), charcoal-fired steaks, legendary BBQ Ribs ($64), and classic ice cream drinks like Pink Squirrel and Grasshopper appeal across generations.

Reservations: Recommended via OpenTable; 15-minute grace period policy.

Washington County features classic supper club Wellington

Wallace Lake Supper Club (Waller's on the Lake)

This quintessential Wisconsin supper club in West Bend serves Wellington as a regular menu item with a world-famous salad bar.

Detail Information Address 2472 Wallace Lake Road, West Bend, WI 53090 Phone (262) 334-4664 Website wallersonthelakewi.com Hours 4pm-9pm (verify current hours) Price Range $$$ (Moderate-upscale supper club)

How it's prepared: Customer reviews describe the Wellington as "very tender" and "fork tender." Pro tip from servers: Order rare for a perfect medium-rare result. One reviewer called it "easily the best meal I've ever had."

Family-friendly features: Classic supper club atmosphere with wood paneling, outdoor seating with lake views, and a fire pit create memorable settings. The "U-shaped" bar fosters friendly atmosphere. Kids particularly enjoy the world-famous salad bar—consistently praised as "best around"—which gives them autonomy in choosing components.

Menu highlights for families: Pan-fried walleye (considered exceptional), French onion soup, German Night specials (schnitzel with mustard cream sauce), dry-aged prime rib, frog legs, and cheese curds offer true Wisconsin supper club breadth.

Reservations: Recommended. Accepts credit cards; takeout available.

Note: Now under new ownership; formerly Wallace Lake Supper Club, currently operating as Waller's on the Lake.

North Shore has one possible option worth investigating

Three Lions Pub

This authentic British pub owned by Brits shows TripAdvisor photo evidence of Beef Wellington, though it doesn't appear on the current regular menu.

Detail Information Address 4515 N Oakland Avenue, Shorewood, WI 53211 Phone (414) 763-6992 Website threelionspub.com Hours Mon-Thu 11am-12am, Fri 11am-1am, Sat 9am-1am, Sun 9am-12am Price Range $$ (Casual dining)

Beef Wellington status: May have been a past special or could be available by request—call to inquire if they can prepare Wellington by special arrangement.

Family-friendly features: The giant 24oz pretzel from Milwaukee Pretzel Company delights kids. Award-winning Sticky Toffee Pudding satisfies dessert cravings. Quiz Night Wednesdays, $1 wing night Thursdays, and Friday Fish Fry provide value-oriented family options. Premier League soccer viewing adds entertainment.

Western suburbs round out the search

Fleming's Prime Steakhouse & Wine Bar

This national chain's Brookfield location appears in Yelp's Beef Wellington category.

Detail Information Address 15665 West Bluemound Road, Brookfield, WI 53005 Phone (262) 782-9463 Website flemingssteakhouse.com Hours Mon-Sat 11am-10pm, Sun 11am-9pm Price Range $$$$ (Fine dining)

Beef Wellington availability: May be available as special or limited item—call to confirm.

Family-friendly features: USDA Prime steaks and 400+ wine selections create celebration atmosphere. Private dining rooms with conferencing capabilities accommodate extended family gatherings. Location near Brookfield Conference Center provides convenient access.

Planning your Beef Wellington adventure

For guaranteed Wellington any night: The Packing House remains the clear winner—it's a permanent menu fixture with 50+ years of perfecting the dish.

For the most luxurious experience: The Commodore's black truffle preparation at $150-180 for two delivers fine-dining excellence with lakeside views.

For a historic multi-course event: Red Circle Inn's ticketed Wellington dinners offer wine pairings and appetizer courses in Wisconsin's oldest restaurant.

For classic supper club atmosphere: Wallace Lake Supper Club and Joey Gerard's both deliver authentic Wisconsin supper club ambiance alongside their Wellington offerings.

Best value: The Packing House at $59.99 includes salad/soup, bread, vegetables, and choice of side—comprehensive for the price.

Most family-friendly overall: The Packing House wins again with their drive-through Friday Fish Fry, lunch service, casual atmosphere, and wide menu variety accommodating picky eaters.

Timing and reservation tips

Beef Wellington requires careful preparation, so restaurants appreciate advance notice. For guaranteed availability, especially at locations offering Wellington as a rotating special, call ahead the day you plan to visit. Weekend dinner reservations should be made several days in advance at popular spots like The Commodore and Red Circle Inn.

Most supper clubs serve Wellington at dinner only—typically beginning service around 4pm or 5pm. The Packing House uniquely offers lunch Tuesday-Friday, though Wellington availability during lunch hours should be confirmed.

What to tell the kids

Beef Wellington makes an excellent introduction to "fancy food" for children. The pastry exterior feels familiar (like a savory croissant), while the tender beef inside rewards adventurous eating. Consider ordering one for the table to share alongside kid-friendlier entrées—most restaurants will slice it for family-style tasting.

For children not ready for Wellington, every restaurant on this list offers approachable alternatives: Friday fish fry, prime rib, burgers, or the famous salad bars at supper clubs let everyone participate in the celebration without pressure.

Whether you're celebrating a milestone birthday, marking an anniversary, or simply craving something extraordinary on a weekend evening, Milwaukee's Beef Wellington destinations deliver memorable experiences across every price point and atmosphere. Start with The Packing House for a reliable weeknight option, then work your way through the supper clubs and fine-dining spots for special occasions—your family's new culinary tradition awaits.