The Best Burgers in Sheboygan, Ranked

Sheboygan gets all the glory for its brats, and rightly so, but the city quietly turns out some of the best burgers on Wisconsin's lakeshore. From the North Shore it's an easy hour up I-43, which makes Sheboygan a perfect day-trip when you want a burger that tastes like somewhere instead of just somewhere fast. We worked our way through the lineup and ranked the standouts from bottom to top, saving the very best for last. Every spot below is open and serving, so you can plan your drive with confidence.

5. Tom's Drive In

Start your tour where Sheboygan has been parking and eating since 1960. Tom's Drive In on Superior Avenue is the throwback of the bunch, a true drive-in with a swift drive-thru, a golf-themed dining room, and a menu built for families on the move. The burgers here are unfussy and consistent, the kind you order with a side of cheese curds and a hand-dipped shake without overthinking it. It lands at the bottom of this list only because the competition gets so fierce above it, not because anything is wrong with a classic griddle patty done right. Kids love it, the prices stay friendly, and it's open every day, which is more than most spots in town can say. Think of it as the dependable opener rather than the main event.

4. The Northwestern House

Tucked just over the railroad tracks on Union Avenue, The Northwestern House has been a neighborhood institution since 2001, and it wears its old-timey railroad theme proudly. Most regulars come for the broasted chicken and the daily fish fry, but the burgers hold their own as honest, no-frills bar fare served the Sheboygan way. The room is cozy and a little kitschy, the staff treats you like a regular by your second visit, and the homemade tortes are reason enough to leave room for dessert. Two things to remember before you go: it's cash only, and it's closed Sunday and Monday, opening Tuesday through Saturday from late morning into the evening. Show up hungry, bring bills, and settle in for a meal that feels like somebody's family kitchen.

3. Black Pig

For the burger you order when you want to dress up a little, head downtown to Black Pig across from the Weill Center. This is Sheboygan's gastropub, a high-ceilinged, exposed-brick room with a from-scratch kitchen and a wine list so deep it earned a Wine Spectator nod. The burgers are built on Niman Ranch prime beef and finished with serious toppings, from aged Wisconsin cheddar to duck confit and house-made brioche, which puts them in a different league than anything griddled at a counter. You'll pay more here, and a few diners think the prices push it, but for a date night or a celebration burger it delivers an experience the casual spots can't match. Reserve a table on a Friday or Saturday night and make an evening of it.

2. Schulz's Restaurant

Now we're into the burgers that put Sheboygan on the map. Schulz's has been charcoal-grilling since 1953, and almost nothing has changed, which is exactly the point. The patties hit the open grill, the famous Hi-Lo Bakery hard rolls get slathered with real butter, and the whole thing comes wrapped in paper at a counter that feels frozen in the best decade. Locals will tell you the steak sandwich is the move, but the burger carries the same buttery, smoky soul and has the kind of flavor you simply cannot fake. It's cash only and closed Sundays, so plan accordingly. A true Sheboygan icon, Schulz's would top almost any other city's list, and it takes the runner-up spot here only because one place edges it out.

1. Local Press Eatery

The best burger in Sheboygan comes off the griddle at Local Press Eatery on South 8th Street, and once you taste it the ranking makes sense. The team grinds black Angus beef fresh every single day and presses it into juicy, lacy-edged smash burgers that have earned the place a near-perfect local reputation. The menu rewards the curious, with signature builds like the Juicy Brucie and a rotating list of monthly specials that range from truffle-topped to wildly inventive, and the hand-cut fries, truffle fries, and big sides keep pace with the burgers. The room is bright, spotless, and friendly, and the line at peak lunch is the only real downside, though every regular will tell you it's worth the wait. If you only have time for one burger in Sheboygan, make it this one.

Plan your Sheboygan burger run

You can hit all five in a weekend if you pace yourself, or build a single perfect afternoon around two: lunch at Local Press, then a buttery nightcap burger at Schulz's before the drive home. Mind the cash-only spots and the Sunday and Monday closures, come hungry, and let the lakeshore breeze earn you a second order of cheese curds. However you rank them, Sheboygan's burger scene more than holds its own.

Now cast your vote — which one's the real champ?

🍔 Reader vote: Sheboygan's best burger

Tap your pick — one vote per reader. Results appear after you vote.

Liked this poll? 🍔

Get our best Wisconsin food finds, day trips, and family adventures — free in your inbox.