The Best Vegan Cakes in Greater Milwaukee: Your complete guide

Milwaukee's vegan cake scene has matured into a robust ecosystem offering everything from allergen-free artisan creations to custom wedding cakes to grab-and-go treats. The clear standout is Blooming Lotus Gourmet Bakery, which operates two locations with a 100% dedicated allergen-free kitchen, though several excellent alternatives serve different needs. One notable loss: Classy Girl Cupcakes, long a go-to for vegan wedding cakes, permanently closed on December 23, 2025.

This guide organizes options by type of establishment, with detailed information verified from business websites, Google listings, and recent 2024-2025 reviews. Most vegan cakes require 48 hours to one week advance notice, so plan accordingly for special occasions.

Dedicated vegan bakeries

These establishments operate 100% vegan kitchens, eliminating cross-contamination concerns for those with dietary restrictions or ethical commitments.

Blooming Lotus Gourmet Bakery

The gold standard for vegan baking in Milwaukee, Blooming Lotus operates a dedicated commercial kitchen free of nine major allergens including gluten, dairy, eggs, soy, and processed sugar. Using nut and seed flours with fruit-based sweeteners, they've created a loyal following among those who thought they'd never enjoy bakery treats again.

East Side Location

• Address: 2215 East North Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53202

• Phone: (414) 212-8010

• Hours: Wednesday–Saturday 7:30 AM–1:00 PM; Sunday 9:00 AM–1:00 PM; Closed Monday–Tuesday

Shorewood Location

• Address: 3948 North Maryland Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53211

• Phone: (414) 800-5030

• Hours: Saturday–Sunday 9:00 AM–1:00 PM only

Website: www.blbmke.com | Email: info@blbmke.com

Cake Offerings & Pricing:

• Custom Layer Cakes: 6" ($50, serves 4-7), 7" ($60, serves 8-11), 9" ($85, serves 12-16), Sheet ($95)

• Flavors: Chocolate Brownie, Vanilla, Carrot Cake with Toffee Frosting

• Specialty Cakes: Chocolate Turtle ($60-$95), Caramel Dream ($110), Strawberry Dream Chocolate ($110), Mocha Hazelnut ($110)

• Pies: $42 (French Silk, Banana Cream, Pumpkin, Coconut Cream, Pecan Brownie)

• Cupcakes: $5.50 regular, $2.75 mini

• Multi-tier wedding cakes available

Allergen Profile: Grain-free, gluten-free, dairy-free, egg-free, soy-free, corn-free, processed sugar-free, oil-free, yeast-free. Contains tree nuts (almond, cashew, seed flours are primary ingredients).

Ordering: Walk-in for daily items. Call 48 hours ahead for double-layer cakes; 10 days for larger or custom designs. Ships biscotti nationwide.

Customer Verdict: "The best ever bakery, one of a kind in the whole US. It was wonderful to walk into a bakery and be able to eat ANYTHING!" Yelp shows consistent praise for taste that rivals conventional baked goods.

CupKate

Milwaukee's premier home-based vegan bakery has earned a devoted following for cupcakes and cakes that taste indistinguishable from their non-vegan counterparts. Owner Kate operates under Wisconsin's Cottage Food law, offering online ordering with arranged pickup.

• Phone: (414) 364-4849

• Website: cupkatemke.com

• Instagram: @cupkatemke

• Location: Milwaukee, WI 53201 (home bakery—pickup only)

• Hours: Monday–Saturday 8:00 AM–8:00 PM; Closed Sunday

Cake Offerings:

• Custom Cakes: 6" and 8" sizes in multiple flavors

• Cupcakes (minimum 6): Classic (Chocolate, Vanilla, Marble), Specialty (Café Mocha, Cinnamon Roll, Coconut Lime, Cookies and Cream, Lavender, Lemon Raspberry, Mint Chocolate Chip, Neapolitan, Banana Bread, Pancake)

• "Caketails" (cocktail-inspired): Margarita, Irish Cream, Baileys

• Brownies (8"x8" pan), Buckle Cakes

Allergen Profile: 100% vegan, egg-free, dairy-free, peanut-free, no artificial dyes (uses fruit/vegetable-based colors). Contains gluten and soy. Uses almond milk.

Ordering: Complete online form; response within 24 hours. Minimum 2 days notice for cupcakes, 1 week for cakes. Payment via PayPal invoice. No custom designs—items come as pictured.

Customer Verdict: Finalist for "Best Cupcakes" in Shepherd Express Best of Milwaukee 2020. Reviews consistently note: "You would never know these cupcakes are vegan! They are so moist and the frosting is so creamy." Kate has delivered wedding cakes as far as Green Bay.

HoochMKE

HoochMKE

Milwaukee's newest vegan bakery opened its brick-and-mortar location in Bay View on November 7, 2025, after building a following at farmers markets. Owner Casey Elliott specializes in vegan sourdough with the philosophy: "If you can tell it's vegan, I didn't do my job right."

• Address: 3040 S. Delaware Ave., Bay View, Milwaukee, WI (inside MKE Outdoor Indoor Exchange)

• Website: hoochmke.com

• Hours: Friday 6:00 AM–2:00 PM; Saturday–Sunday 8:00 AM–2:00 PM

Offerings:

• Cupcakes, Cinnamon Rolls (including sweet potato pie variety), Carrot Cakes

• Croissants, Danish, Swedish Cardamom Knots

• Apple Cider Doughnuts (seasonal)

• Sourdough breads, focaccia, bagels with house-made vegan cream cheese

• Cheesecake (coming soon)

Special Features: Uses organic, local, fair-trade ingredients; wild sourdough yeast; flour from local mills. House-made vegan meats and cheeses for sandwiches.

Compassionate Cake

This custom cake business, run by MATC culinary arts graduate Jessica Kelter-Weisnicht, has operated since at least 2011, building a reputation for artistic designs and over 80 flavor combinations.

• Phone: (262) 902-1986

• Location: Milwaukee, WI 53201 (Menomonee River Valley area)

Specialties: Custom birthday, wedding, and special occasion cakes. Signature flavors include Rosewater, Blood Orange, Chocolate Whoopie Pie, Strawberry Shortcake, Maple Caramel "Smart Bacon," Banana Split, White Chocolate Cheesecake with Biscoff Cookie Crust.

Ingredient Sourcing: Penzey's spices, Rishi Tea, Anodyne coffee, homemade vanilla extract, farmers market produce.

Customer Verdict: "Her cakes and pastries are top notch. Some of the best I've ever had, period. And on top of it all, they are vegan! The owner is a true artist. She creates beautiful designs and is able to copy most pictures."

Note: Verify current availability by calling, as online presence is limited.

Bunny's Bite

This 100% vegan and gluten-free business operates wholesale through Milwaukee cafes and at farmers markets and events, with an online shop for direct orders.

• Website: bunnysbite.com

• Online Shop: bunnys-bite.myshopify.com

• Instagram: @bunnysbite

Where to Find Products:

• Rochambo Coffee and Tea House

• Celesta

• Beerline Cafe

• Alderaan Coffee

• Vennture

• Brew-Jas Coffee House (3060 S. 13th St.)

• Marquette University campus

• Twisted Plants (Bay View)

• Madison Vegan Pop-Up markets

Offerings: Chocolate Chunk Cookies, Double Chocolate Pistachio Cookies, Peanut Butter Cookies, Peanut Butter Cup Cookie Bars, Brownies, Banana Bread, Cheesecakes, Pies. Gift cards available ($10-$500).

Dulce MKE

A specialty bakery focusing on vegan and gluten-free creations, operating from Cudahy with delivery to the Milwaukee area.

• Website: dulcemke.square.site

Offerings: Vegan gluten-free cakes, egg-free cakes, dairy-free cakes, "Crumbl-style" cookies, custom orders.

Traditional bakeries accommodate vegan requests

These established bakeries maintain separate vegan options alongside conventional products. Cross-contamination is possible; those with severe allergies should discuss protocols directly.

Outpost Natural Foods Bakehouse

This community-owned co-op operates four locations with in-house bakeries offering custom vegan cakes made from scratch with organic ingredients and plant-based natural colors.

Locations:

• Capitol Drive: 100 E. Capitol Drive, Milwaukee, WI 53212 | (414) 961-2597

• Wauwatosa: 7000 W. State Street, Wauwatosa, WI 53213 | (414) 778-2012

• Bay View: 2826 S. Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207 | (414) 755-3202

• Mequon: 7590 W. Mequon Road, Mequon, WI 53092 | (262) 242-0426

Website: www.outpost.coop/bakehouse

Vegan Offerings: Custom decorated cakes (vegan and gluten-free available), prepackaged cookies, cupcakes, cake slices, bars, banana bread, pumpkin bread. Never uses artificial colors, flavors, or trans fats.

Ordering: Place orders at any store's prepared foods/café department. Minimum 48 hours notice (extra 24-48 hours for Friday-Saturday pickup). Payment required at ordering.

Greige Patisserie

This French-inspired bakery in Walker's Point accommodates vegan requests for custom orders, including wedding cakes.

• Address: 408 W Florida St, Suite 104, Milwaukee, WI 53204

• Phone: (414) 252-0143

• Website: www.greigemke.com

• Hours: Wednesday–Saturday 7:30 AM–5:00 PM; Sunday 8:00 AM–12:00 PM; Closed Monday–Tuesday

Vegan Options: Gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan cake options available upon request. Can accommodate vegan cupcakes for weddings/events. Minimum 3 days notice for specialty cakes.

Customer Note: "They also were easily able to accommodate when we added a dozen vegan, gluten-free cupcakes to our order after our RSVPs had come in."

Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop

This third-generation family bakery in West Allis offers limited vegan options alongside their traditional specialties.

• Address: 7328 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis, WI 53214

• Phone: (414) 482-1288

• Website: www.aggiesbakery.com

• Hours: Monday–Friday 7:00 AM–6:00 PM; Saturday 7:00 AM–5:00 PM; Sunday 7:00 AM–1:00 PM

Note: Limited vegan options; call ahead to confirm availability. Seven-time Couple's Choice Award winner for wedding cakes.

MOR Bakery & Cafe

A dedicated gluten-free bakery where many items are also vegan.

• Address: 5504 W. State Street, Milwaukee, WI 53208

• Website: www.morfoodsmke.com

• Hours: Thursday–Friday 11:00 AM–5:30 PM; Saturday 9:00 AM–1:00 PM

Vegan + GF Offerings: Mini chocolate chip cookies (3 for $0.99), brownies, bars, cheesecake tarts. Focus on affordable pricing.

North Shore communities have growing options

Residents of Shorewood, Whitefish Bay, Fox Point, Bayside, Glendale, and Mequon have several local options plus easy access to Milwaukee's dedicated vegan bakeries.

Shorewood

Blooming Lotus Gourmet Bakery (see above) maintains their second location at 3948 North Maryland Avenue, open Saturday–Sunday only.

North Shore Boulangerie (4401 N. Oakland Avenue, 414-963-2153) is a traditional French bakery—contact directly about vegan accommodations.

The City Market Café & Bakehouse (4000 N. Oakland Avenue) features a dedicated plant-based menu section; inquire about vegan desserts.

Whitefish Bay

Fitzy's Café (424 E. Silver Spring Drive, 414-356-1424) offers a Vegan Dirt Cake among other options. Reviews call it a "hidden gem."

Stone Creek Coffee + Kitchen (527 E. Silver Spring Drive) opened a scratch-made pastry program in 2023—check current menu for vegan options.

Fox Point

Friendship Cafe & Bakery (8649 N. Port Washington Road, 414-755-5855) is a nut-free, Kosher café employing adults with disabilities, with vegan menu items and seasonal specialty cakes. Hours: Monday–Thursday 7:30 AM–4:30 PM, Friday 7:30 AM–3:00 PM, Sunday 9:00 AM–4:30 PM, Closed Saturday.

Mequon

Outpost Natural Foods (7590 W. Mequon Road, 262-242-0426) offers custom vegan cakes with 48-hour notice (see full details above).

Glendale

Stone Creek Coffee (6969 N. Port Washington Road) maintains a scratch pastry program—check for vegan options.

Bayside

No dedicated vegan bakeries identified. Nearest options are Fox Point's Friendship Cafe or Glendale's Stone Creek. Blooming Lotus East Side (2215 E. North Ave) is approximately 10 minutes south.

Restaurants and cafes serving notable vegan desserts

Several Milwaukee establishments have built reputations for exceptional vegan desserts beyond typical bakery offerings.

Cafe Manna (Brookfield)

• Website: cafemanna.com

• Type: First 100% vegetarian restaurant in Southeastern Wisconsin (since 2008)

• Vegan Desserts: Chocolacados (signature), Chocolate Chip Cookie Torte, weekly specials

• All items clearly marked vegan/raw/gluten-free

Strange Town

• Address: 2101 N. Prospect Ave, Milwaukee

• Website: strangetownmke.com

• Type: 100% vegan small plates restaurant with rotating dessert menu

Odd Duck

• Type: Upscale fine dining

• Notable: Highly praised vegan cheesecake and daily vegan options

• Reservations recommended

Twisted Plants (100% Vegan Fast Food)

• Brady Street: 1233 E. Brady St, (414) 837-3038

• Website: twistedplants.com

• Desserts: Signature Carrot Cake, vegan ice cream, milkshakes

• Black-owned business

Beerline Cafe

• Address: 2076 N. Commerce St, Milwaukee

• Phone: (414) 265-5644

• Website: beerlinecafe.com

• Type: Fast-casual vegetarian (most items can be made vegan)

• Carries Bunny's Bite vegan desserts; sweet crepes with vegan options

• Delivers to Milwaukee, Shorewood, and surrounding areas

Dead Bird Brewing

• Type: 100% vegan brewery and restaurant

• Full vegan menu including desserts; arcade games, outdoor patio

Beans & Barley

• Address: 1901 E. North Ave, Milwaukee

• Phone: (414) 278-7878

• Website: beansandbarley.com

• Health-conscious café and organic market since 1973

• Selection of pies and cakes at deli counter

On The Bus (Milwaukee Public Market)

• Location: 400 N. Water St (served from a '71 VW bus)

• Type: 100% vegan quick-service

• Oat milk ice cream, smoothies, acai bowls, date shakes, milkshake specials Wednesdays

Grocery stores stock reliable vegan cake options

Outpost Natural Foods (4 locations)

The best local grocery option for vegan cakes. Custom orders available at all locations with 48-hour notice. Prepackaged sweets always in stock.

Whole Foods Market

Multiple Milwaukee area locations carry:

• JPS Pastry Vegan Vanilla Cake (6-inch)

• JPS Pastry Vegan Red Velvet Cake (6-inch)

• Just Desserts Chocolate Midnight Cake (20 oz)

• Rubicon Bakers Vegan Birthday Layer Cake (4-inch)

• Vegan Vanilla Cupcakes

Contact bakery team for customization at select stores.

Trader Joe's

Budget-friendly rotating selection includes:

• Cheese-Less "Cheesecakes"

• Non-Dairy Oat Frozen Dessert

• Mini Non-Dairy Ice Cream Cones

• Dairy-Free Banana Bread (egg-free)

• Vegan Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies

• Various seasonal items

Purple Door Ice Cream

• Vegan Purple Moon shake

• 2-3 rotating vegan ice cream flavors

• Check for vegan ice cream cake availability

Annual events showcase Milwaukee's vegan dessert scene

VeganMania Milwaukee

• When: June 2025 at Greenfield Park

• Admission: FREE

• Features vegan bakeries, food trucks, beverages, market exhibitors

Milwaukee Vegan Restaurant Week

• When: November 3-9, 2025 (National Vegan Month)

• Participants: 29+ local establishments

• Notable dessert highlights: Gather Bakehouse (vegan donuts, cheesecake, croissant), Odd Duck (vegan dessert tasting), Purple Door Ice Cream, Honeypie Café (vegan apple pie)

• Contact: steph@corazonmilwaukee.com

Quick reference by need

If You Need... Best Option Allergen-free (GF + vegan) Blooming Lotus Bakery Traditional-tasting vegan cake CupKate Custom artistic designs Compassionate Cake Vegan + GF grab-and-go Bunny's Bite (at cafes) North Shore pickup Blooming Lotus Shorewood or Outpost Mequon Same-day availability Blooming Lotus (walk-in daily items) Wedding cakes CupKate, Blooming Lotus, or Greige Patisserie Budget-friendly MOR Bakery or Trader Joe's Fine dining dessert Odd Duck

Ordering timeline guide

• Walk-in daily items: Blooming Lotus, Outpost (prepackaged)

• 48 hours minimum: Outpost custom cakes, Blooming Lotus double-layer cakes

• 3+ days: Greige Patisserie custom orders

• 1 week minimum: CupKate custom cakes

• 10+ days: Blooming Lotus large/custom designs

• Wedding cakes: Consultation required; book 2-3 months ahead

Conclusion

Milwaukee's vegan cake landscape offers genuine quality across price points and dietary needs. Blooming Lotus remains the definitive choice for those managing multiple food allergies, while CupKate excels at delivering conventional cake experiences in vegan form. The November 2025 opening of HoochMKE signals continued growth in the market. For North Shore residents, the combination of Blooming Lotus Shorewood on weekends and Outpost Mequon for custom orders covers most needs without traveling into the city.

The closure of Classy Girl Cupcakes leaves a gap in the wedding cake market, but CupKate, Blooming Lotus, and Greige Patisserie all accommodate vegan wedding orders. Plan ahead—nearly all specialty vegan cakes require advance notice, with wedding cakes needing consultation 2-3 months before your event.