Best Sub Sandwiches in Greater Milwaukee: The Ultimate Guide

Seeking the perfect sub sandwich in southeastern Wisconsin? This guide covers more than 65 shops spanning Milwaukee proper through Ozaukee, Waukesha, Washington, Racine, and Kenosha counties.

Whether you crave an authentic Italian hoagie, a cheesesteak dripping with molten cheese, or a fresh-baked bánh mì, this comprehensive directory will help you plan delicious adventures across the region. We've organized everything geographically so you can combine sub runs with other family outings—because the best lunch is one that's on your way.

Milwaukee's sub sandwich scene reflects the city's blue-collar heritage and immigrant traditions, from Sicilian delis that have operated for four generations to Wisconsin-born chains that have become regional institutions. You'll find shops where the bread comes from Peter Sciortino's legendary bakery, delis where the muffaletta recipe hasn't changed since 1946, and cheesesteak joints that would make Philadelphia proud.

The North Shore and Ozaukee County

For North Shore families, these spots offer the best combination of quality, convenience, and kid-friendly environments.

The Chocolate Factory

Address: W62 N577 Washington Avenue, Cedarburg, WI 53012
Phone: (262) 377-8877
Hours: Monday–Saturday 10:30 AM–9:00 PM; Sunday 11:00 AM–8:00 PM
Website: thechocolatefactorywi.com

This family-owned gem has been combining award-winning subs with Wisconsin ice cream for over 50 years. The secret is bread baked fresh in small batches throughout the day, plus a homemade "special mayonnaise" that's remained a family recipe since the Nixon administration. Signature subs include The Phoenix (turkey, jalapeño bacon, pepper jack, chipotle mayo), The Sicilian (Italian meats with house dressing), and the Italian Beef with au jus for dipping. Half subs run $4–8, whole subs $8–12.

For families, the magic is the ice cream counter—26 flavors of Wisconsin-made ice cream visible right at kid height. Order a mini sub kids meal (includes chips, drink, and cookie), then let them pick their sundae flavors. The historic downtown Cedarburg location features cute booths and casual table seating. Party Round Subs feed 12 people for group events, and their Traveling Sundae Factory brings the ice cream bar to you.

Out & Out Custard, Eatery & Catering — Cedarburg's dietary-friendly favorite

Address: W61N305 Washington Avenue, Cedarburg, WI 53012
Phone: (262) 377-5515
Hours: Daily 10:00 AM–8:00 PM
Website: outandoutcustard.com

If you have family members with gluten sensitivities, Out & Out is your spot. They offer brown rice pasta, quinoa tortillas, and millet bread substitutions across their menu. The signature item is their famous mac & cheese (18+ years of recognition), but the hot sandwiches on rustic ciabatta deserve attention: try the Americano, Chipotle Chicken, or the Cuban. Paninis run $10–15, with box lunches at $10.99 for easy grab-and-go.

This employee-owned restaurant features a large outdoor patio for nice weather and extensive catering services throughout the North Shore ($35–55 delivery fee by zone). Uber Eats available for home delivery.

Kurt Schulz Delicatessen & Pastry Shoppe — Brown Deer's hidden gem

Address: 8752 North Deerwood Drive, Brown Deer, WI 53209
Phone: (414) 354-1004
Hours: Tuesday–Saturday 6:30 AM–3:00 PM; closed Sunday–Monday
Website: kurtschulzdeli.com

This old-school Milwaukee deli offers something special: Wednesday "Sub Day" when locals pack the shop for discounted turkey, ham, and roast beef subs loaded with lettuce, tomato, onion, American cheese, a slice of salami, and oil & vinegar dressing on hoagie rolls. Every sub comes with that signature deli attention—handmade everything from the bread to the German potato salad.

Beyond subs, the pastry case will captivate kids with tortes, custom birthday cakes, and fresh-baked cookies. Sandwiches run $6–10, soups $3–5. The family-owned shop hosts private parties and offers extensive catering (minimum 10 people) including sandwich trays, bag lunches, and hot items like lasagna.

Benji's Deli & Restaurant — Fox Point's New York-style landmark

Address: 8683 N Port Washington Road, Fox Point, WI 53217
Phone: (414) 228-5130
Hours: Daily 10:00 AM–3:00 PM (verify current hours)
Website: benjisdeliandrestaurant.com

A Milwaukee institution since 1963, Benji's piles hand-carved corned beef and pastrami onto sandwiches that would make a Manhattan deli jealous. The signature sandwich is The Hear-O-Israel: quarter-pound each of pastrami, salami, corned beef, and peppered beef with Swiss, coleslaw, and Thousand Island. Classic Reubens and Rachels round out the menu, with matzoh ball soup for cold days.

At $12–18 per sandwich, this is premium territory, but portions are generous enough to share with younger kids. The Fox Point location has better parking than the original Shorewood spot, plus easy I-43 access. Dogs allowed, delivery through DoorDash, Uber Eats, Grubhub, and Postmates.

Cousins Subs — Glendale's flagship Wisconsin location

Address: 5333 N Port Washington Road, Glendale, WI 53217
Phone: (414) 962-6575
Hours: Daily 10:00 AM–10:00 PM
Website: cousinssubs.com

This remodeled flagship location features the new "Milwaukee Sub Shop" design with Sprecher Root Beer on tap, Wisconsin cheese curds, and chocolate and vanilla shakes made with Wisconsin dairy. The "Project Henry" make line lets kids watch their sub being assembled. Drive-thru available for families on the go.

Additional North Shore/Ozaukee Cousins locations:

• Port Washington: 101 E Grand Avenue (262-268-9803)

• Mequon: 1424 W Mequon Rd (262-241-7010)

• Brown Deer: 5151 W Brown Deer Rd

All locations offer kids meals (5" sub with applesauce and juice box), with subs running $8–15. Party Boxes for catering require 90 minutes notice, 24 hours for large orders.

Jersey Mike's Subs — Mequon

Address: 10930 N. Port Washington Road, Mequon, WI 53092
Phone: (262) 236-9199
Hours: Open 7 days, 10:00 AM–9:00 PM
Website: jerseymikes.com/29031/mequon-wi

Jersey Mike's distinctive feature is watching your meats and cheeses sliced fresh in front of you—entertaining for kids and proof of freshness for skeptical adults. Ask for your sub "Mike's Way" (fresh lettuce, onions, tomatoes, oil, vinegar, and spices) for the signature East Coast experience. Popular choices include the #13 Italian and Big Kahuna Cheesesteak. Regular subs run $9–14.

Catering options include subs by the box, personal boxed lunches, and cookie/brownie trays for parties.

Firehouse Subs — Grafton Marketplace

Address: 1550 Port Washington Road, Grafton, WI 53024
Phone: (262) 421-5566
Hours: Daily 10:00 AM–9:00 PM
Website: firehousesubs.com

Founded by firefighters, Firehouse features premium meats steamed hot and piled high on toasted private-recipe rolls. The firefighter-themed décor with authentic memorabilia and rescue equipment captivates kids. Try the Hook & Ladder (ham and turkey with melted Monterey Jack), New York Steamer (pastrami and corned beef), or the Firehouse Meatball. Medium/large subs run $8–12.

Kid's meals include the Kid's Meatball Combo. Health score: 98/100. Delivery via DoorDash and Uber Eats.

Jimmy John's — Mequon

Address: 11525 N Port Washington Rd, Mequon, WI 53092
Website: locations.jimmyjohns.com

Known for "Freaky Fast" delivery, Jimmy John's bakes French bread fresh throughout the day (served within 4 hours of the oven). The simple menu with hand-sliced meats appeals to picky eaters. Subs run $7–11. Unwich lettuce wraps available for low-carb family members.

Milwaukee

From Brady Street's Italian heritage to Bay View's eclectic scene, Milwaukee proper offers the region's most diverse sub landscape.

Glorioso's Italian Market — Milwaukee's Italian landmark since 1946

Address: 1011 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: (414) 272-0540
Hours: Monday–Friday 9:00 AM–7:00 PM; Saturday 8:00 AM–6:00 PM; Sunday 8:30 AM–5:00 PM
Website: gloriosos.com

Founded by brothers Joe, Eddie, and Ted Glorioso, this East Side institution has won "Milwaukee's Best Deli" from OnMilwaukee every year since 2009. The Milwaukee Muffaletta is legendary, alongside fresh-made sausages using Nonno Felice's original recipe. Beyond the deli counter, browse aisles of imported Italian specialty items with kids—it's essentially a mini food museum.

The bakery-café offers indoor and outdoor seating. Cooking classes available through their Appetito program. Note: The store experienced fire damage in October 2025—call ahead to verify current operating status.

Scardina Specialties — Riverwest's Sicilian treasure

Address: 715 E Locust St, Milwaukee, WI 53212
Phone: (414) 395-3369
Hours: Tuesday–Friday 9:00 AM–7:00 PM; Saturday 9:00 AM–5:00 PM; Sunday 8:00 AM–3:00 PM; closed Monday
Website: scardinas.com

Family recipes brought directly from Sicily make Scardina a neighborhood institution. The Hot Italian Beef Sandwich draws devoted followers, alongside the Cubano Panini ($7–12) and signature Spiedini (Sicilian skewers with beef, pork, or chicken rolled in breadcrumbs with onions, currants, and pine nuts). Handmade Italian sausages and take-and-bake pizzas ($12–16) round out the menu.

The small space has just 3 tables, so call ahead for larger orders. Dogs allowed, beer available while you wait, and parking validation offered. The shop reopened in December 2022 at this new location after their previous building was condemned.

Gouda's Italian Deli — Downtown's affordable Italian option

Address: 218 N. Water Street, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: (414) 221-6565
Hours: Monday–Friday 10:00 AM–6:00 PM; Saturday 10:00 AM–5:00 PM; closed Sunday
Website: goudasitaliandeli.com

Part of the SURG Restaurant Group, Gouda's offers incredible value: the Tommy Gun (Genoa salami, mortadella, capocollo, calabrese, imported prosciutto, provolone, muffalatta mix) runs just $9.95 for a full sandwich. The Luciano (tuna, tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil) and vegetarian Greta Garbo offer variety at $6.95–$8.95.

The intimate corner space works best for grab-and-go or small families. Italian sodas, cannoli ($2.25), and specialty dried goods available for purchase. Curb-side delivery and catering services offered.

Fonzarelli's Italian Deli — Third Street Market Hall

Address: 275 W. Wisconsin Ave (3rd St. Market Hall, South Hall 1st Floor), Milwaukee, WI 53203
Hours: Monday–Thursday 11:00 AM–9:00 PM; Friday–Saturday 11:00 AM–11:00 PM; Sunday 11:00 AM–7:00 PM

Opened October 2024, this retro-themed deli pays homage to Milwaukee's "Happy Days" connection with Fonzie décor. All sandwiches feature Sciortino's bread. The Classic Italian (capicola, pepperoni, salami with Italian oil, vinegar, seasonings) and Papa's Meatball (meatballs, marinara, basil, mozzarella, parmesan) are standouts. Fast-casual pricing keeps it budget-friendly.

The 3rd Street Market Hall location (named 2nd best food hall in the US by USA Today) offers common seating and family entertainment nearby—perfect for groups with different food preferences.

Chubby's Cheesesteaks — Milwaukee's Philly answer

Milwaukee Locations:

• East Side: 2232 N. Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202

• Walker's Point: 605 S. 1st St, Milwaukee, WI 53204

Website: chubbyscheesesteaks.com

Since 2007, Chubby's has been serving authentic Philly-style cheesesteaks on Peter Sciortino Bakery soft rolls. Options range from The Philly (steak or chicken + cheese) to loaded versions with fried onions, peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo. The Cheesesteak Fries (fries smothered in cheese whiz and ribeye) are dangerously good.

Mighty Kids Meals available. Multiple locations with dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. Late-night hours for post-event cravings. Catering through ezcater.com.

Cheba Hut "Toasted" Subs — Bay View and East Side

Bay View: 2202 S Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
East Side: 2907 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53212
Hours: Daily 10:00 AM–10:00 PM (extended to midnight–2:00 AM Friday–Saturday)
Website: chebahut.com

This national chain with cannabis-themed décor (note: no actual marijuana in the food) serves 26+ varieties of toasted subs with creative names. The Power Plant (guacamole, hummus, feta) appeals to vegetarians. Full liquor bar with craft cocktails and rotating local beers. Bay View location sits across from a park with parking directly in front.

Kids welcome despite the theme—kid-friendly sub options available. Delivery through DoorDash, Uber Eats, Grubhub, EatStreet.

The Original Suburpia — A Milwaukee legend since the 1970s

Address: 116 E Layton Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207 (Shell gas station location)
Phone: (414) 727-8300
Hours: Monday–Friday 10:30 AM–8:00 PM; Saturday 11:00 AM–8:00 PM; closed Sunday
Website: suburpia.com

Before food delivery apps, before artisan sandwich shops, there was Suburpia—and at its peak, 20+ locations introduced submarine sandwiches to a generation of Milwaukeeans. John Belushi famously sang their radio jingle ads before Saturday Night Live. Today, just three locations remain, serving the same recipe: sesame-seeded rolls made exclusively by Peter Sciortino Bakery, loaded with cheese, mayo, and chopped salad in tangy dressing.

Classic sandwich names include the Gold Coast (ham), Miles Standish (turkey), and Davey Jones (tuna). Subs are served in a bag—meant to be eaten from the bag to catch the signature oil and seasonings. At $6–10, it's exceptional value with nostalgic charm.

Additional Suburpia locations:

• Wauwatosa: 11108 W Bluemound Rd (414-456-1100)

• Waukesha: 1830 N. Grandview Blvd (262-524-8200)

Riley's Social House & Sandwich Co. — Third Ward's upscale option

Address: 411 E Menomonee St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: (414) 316-9118
Hours: Tuesday–Saturday 11:00 AM–10:00 PM; Sunday 11:00 AM–8:00 PM; closed Monday
Website: rileysandwich.com

Using sous-vide technique for perfectly cooked meats, Riley's creates premium sandwiches like the Steak Kensington (sous-vide beef filet, roasted mushrooms, onions, mozzarella, horseradish spread) and Chicken Parmesan with organic chicken breast. Monthly sandwich specials keep the menu fresh.

The dog-friendly establishment features 24 craft beers on tap, outdoor patio seating, and dart boards. Premium pricing ($$-$$$) but worth it for date-night-level sandwiches. Card only, no cash. Party sandwich platters available for catering.

Megawich — Brady Street's halal option

Address: 1426 East Brady Street, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Hours: Monday–Wednesday 11:00 AM–12:00 AM; Thursday closed; Friday–Saturday 11:00 AM–3:00 AM; Sunday 12:00 PM–7:00 PM
Website: megawichwi.com

Specializing in big, high-protein halal sandwiches, Megawich serves the Lower East Side, Riverwest, and Third Ward neighborhoods. The Chicken Powerlifter is highly rated, alongside the Beef Pitcher and Quarterback Burger. Vegetarian options available. Egyptian-seasoned fries add international flair.

Customizable spice levels accommodate different family preferences. Affordable pricing, generous portions, 24-hour catering notice required.

Waukesha County: Suburban Selection from Brookfield to Oconomowoc

Waukesha County offers convenient options for families on the western side of the metro, with The Chocolate Factory's multiple locations making it especially family-friendly.

The Chocolate Factory — Five Waukesha County locations

The Chocolate Factory's expansion makes quality subs accessible throughout the county:

• Pewaukee: 161 W Wisconsin Ave, Suite 1B (262-264-0015) — Across from Pewaukee Beach/Lake with outdoor seating and lake views

• Waukesha: 2120 E Moreland Blvd, Suite J (262-542-5405) — Westbrook Shopping Center

• Oconomowoc: 1077 Summit Avenue (262-567-0625) — "On the beach" location

• Delafield: 3255 Golf Road (262-997-0006)

• Elm Grove: 13475 Watertown Plank Road (262-997-0006) — "Next to waterfall"

• Menomonee Falls: N88W16498 Main Street (262-293-3314)

All locations share the same commitment to fresh-baked rolls, Wisconsin ice cream, and kid-friendly atmosphere. The Pewaukee lakefront location is particularly scenic for summer outings.

Potbelly Sandwich Shop — Brookfield Square

Address: 17800 W Bluemound Rd, Suite A-1, Brookfield, WI 53045
Phone: (262) 796-9845
Hours: Daily 9:00 AM–9:00 PM
Website: potbelly.com

Potbelly's signature oven-toasted sandwiches have earned a loyal following since 1977. The Wreck (turkey, ham, roast beef, salami, Swiss) remains the bestseller. Mediterranean options with hummus and feta offer lighter fare. Hand-dipped shakes are half-off after 3:00 PM weekdays and all weekend—perfect timing for after-school treats.

Fresh-baked cookies appeal to all ages. Located near Brookfield Square mall and the Sharon Lynne Wilson Center for the Arts, making it easy to combine with other family activities.

Marty's Pizza, Pasta & Subs — Brookfield institution since 1957

Address: 16680 W Bluemound Rd, Brookfield, WI 53005
Phone: (262) 782-5830
Hours: Monday–Thursday 11:00 AM–10:00 PM; Friday–Saturday 11:00 AM–11:30 PM; Sunday 12:00 PM–9:00 PM
Website: martyspizza.net

Started as a grocery store in 1957, Marty's evolved into a beloved family restaurant featuring classic thin-crust pizza alongside cold and toasted subs. The Italian Sausage Sub (made with homemade sausage) is a customer favorite. Wooden booths, nostalgic 70s/80s décor, and classic arcade games make this especially kid-friendly.

Subs run $5–11. Outdoor seating available. Catering services up to 2,000 people including party subs, pizza, pasta trays, and taco/fajita bars.

S3 Deli — Hartland's new favorite

Address: 131 E Capitol Dr, Hartland, WI 53029
Phone: (262) 361-0040
Hours: Daily 8:00 AM–8:00 PM
Website: s3deli.com | Instagram: @s3_deli

Opened mid-2024, S3 Deli (Soups, Salads, Sandwiches) focuses on competitive pricing and 5–7 minute service—perfect for busy families. The Pastrami Brisket earns high marks, alongside Italian Meatball and Pepperoni Melt options. Indoor and outdoor seating, wheelchair accessible.

Note: Reports indicate S3 Deli may have adjusted hours—call ahead to confirm.

Cousins Subs — Waukesha County locations

Wisconsin's homegrown chain was founded in Menomonee Falls in 1972, making this essentially their home territory:

• Waukesha - Sunset Dr: 530 W Sunset Dr (262-544-6306)

• Waukesha - Pearl St: 1700 Pearl Street (262-513-9750)

• New Berlin: 16005 W National Ave (262-796-8455)

• Menomonee Falls - Pilgrim Rd: W156 N5530 Pilgrim Rd

• Menomonee Falls - Appleton Ave: Check website

Hours generally 10:00 AM–9:00 PM. Full menu of deli-fresh and grilled-to-order subs, Wisconsin cheese curds, kids meals ($8–15 per sub).

Jersey Mike's Subs — Three Waukesha County locations

• Waukesha: jerseymikes.com/29002/waukesha-wi

• Brookfield: 17550-C W Bluemound Rd, Suite 80 (262-641-7827)

• Pewaukee: 1450 Capitol Dr (262-696-6101)

All open 7 days, 10:00 AM–9:00 PM. Fresh-sliced meats, "Mike's Way" preparation, subs $8–14.

Firehouse Subs — Waukesha County

• Waukesha: 180 E Sunset Dr, Suite C (262-875-3004) — Health Score 99/100

• Menomonee Falls: N92 W16135 Falls Pkwy (262-293-9046) — Extended hours until 10:00 PM

Daily 10:00 AM–9:00 PM (10:00 PM at Menomonee Falls). Hook & Ladder, Firehouse Meatball, and New York Steamer remain popular. $8–14 per sub.

Jimmy John's — Waukesha County

• Waukesha: 315 E North St

• Brookfield - Greenfield Ave: 15500 W Greenfield Ave

• Brookfield - Bluemound: 18900 W Bluemound

• Pewaukee: 1890 Meadow Ln

• Delafield: 2738 Hillside Dr

"Freaky Fast" delivery, $7–11 per sub, Unwich lettuce wrap options for low-carb diets.

Washington County and Northern Suburbs: Small-Town Gems

North of Milwaukee, you'll find independent shops with hometown character alongside reliable chain options.

Angee B'z Subs — Hartford's local favorite

Address: 625A West Sumner Street, Hartford, WI 53027
Phone: (262) 670-6996
Hours: Monday–Thursday 10:00 AM–6:00 PM; Friday 10:00 AM–5:00 PM; Saturday 10:00 AM–4:00 PM; closed Sunday
Website: angeebzsubs.com

This true local independent offers fresh subs, hot subs, paninis, wraps, and homemade soups with unique pretzel roll bread options not found at chains. The "Pick 2" special ($11–$11.50) combines a 4" sub with a cup of soup—perfect for smaller appetites.

Free Wi-Fi, loyalty rewards program, and full catering menu. Delivery available (20% automatic tip). A genuine small-town sub shop experience.

Bieri's Jackson Cheese & Deli — Wisconsin cheese country

Address: 3271 County Road P (Hwy P), Jackson, WI 53037
Phone: (800) 321-6077 or (262) 677-3227
Hours: Tuesday–Friday 10:00 AM–5:00 PM; Saturday 9:00 AM–2:00 PM; closed Sunday–Monday
Website: bierischeese.com

Over 70 years of Wisconsin cheese heritage make Bieri's a destination worth the drive. Signature sandwiches on artisan breads include Turkey with muenster and homemade tangy cranberry mustard, Ham on Sheboygan roll with sharp cheddar and homemade pineapple mustard, and the Wisconsin Summer Sausage with Colby cheese.

Sandwiches run $11–15. Kids get an educational experience seeing Wisconsin cheese culture firsthand—sample cheeses, browse gift baskets, and take home unique local souvenirs. Note: Call ahead to confirm current hours as status may have changed.

Cousins Subs — Hartford

Address: 529 W. Sumner St. (Hwy 60), Hartford, WI 53027
Phone: (262) 670-9945
Hours: Monday–Saturday 9:00 AM–9:00 PM; Sunday 9:00 AM–8:00 PM

Corporate-owned location with full-service drive-thru, digital menu boards, shakes and floats. Recently remodeled with modern "Milwaukee Sub Shop" design. Kids meal options include PB&J. Delivery via Uber Eats and Postmates.

Jersey Mike's — West Bend

Address: 1025 South Main Street, West Bend, WI 53095
Phone: (262) 353-3332
Hours: Open 7 days, 10:00 AM–9:00 PM

Highly rated (4.6 stars, 122+ reviews) with exceptional staff friendliness. Grilled Portobello Cheese offers a vegetarian option. Health score 97/100. Accommodates dietary restrictions including gluten allergies.

Firehouse Subs — West Bend

Address: 1733 S Main Street, West Bend, WI 53095
Phone: (262) 429-2222
Hours: Open 7 days, 10:00 AM–9:00 PM

Full menu including the French Dip ($16) with hot au jus for dipping, plus new fries and Extra Cheesy Mac n Cheese sides ($6.50). Kids Combos with drink and dessert. Health score 98/100. Extensive catering with sub platters, salad platters, and boxed lunches.

Cousins Subs — West Bend (Two locations)

• Paradise Drive: 437 W Paradise Drive (262-334-5606)

• Washington Street: 2320 W Washington Street (262-334-5500)

Hours approximately 10:00 AM–8:00 PM. Owner Keith known for community involvement. Limited-time specials like Chorizo Ham and Chorizo Chicken subs.

Jersey Mike's — Germantown

Address: N112 W16510 Mequon Road, Unit 2, Germantown, WI 53022
Phone: (262) 345-5001
Hours: Open 7 days, 10:00 AM–9:00 PM

Customers specifically praise this location for generous portions—sandwiches "filled to the brim with meat." Top-notch cleanliness rated in reviews.

Cousins Subs — Germantown

Address: N96 W15630 County Line Road, Germantown, WI 53022
Phone: (262) 251-9202
Hours: Daily 10:00 AM–8:00 PM

Perfect health score: 100/100. Established Wisconsin brand since 1972.

Jimmy John's — Germantown (Two locations)

• N112 W16268 Mequon Road

• N96 W17980 County Line Road

Fresh-baked French bread (less than 4 hours old), hand-sliced meats. "Freaky Fast" service.

Racine and Kenosha Counties: Southern Treasures

The southern edge of the metro area offers exceptional Italian delis and local institutions.

Tenuta's Delicatessen — Kenosha's legendary Italian market since 1950

Address: 3203 52nd Street, Kenosha, WI 53144
Phone: (262) 657-9001
Hours: Monday–Thursday 9:00 AM–8:00 PM; Friday–Saturday 9:00 AM–9:00 PM; Sunday 9:00 AM–5:00 PM
Website: tenutasdeli.com | @tenutasdeli

"Your Shortest Route to Italy" has been serving Kenosha for four generations. The signature Muffo-Lotta (pepperoni, Genoa salami, mortadella, ham, provolone, mild peppers, lettuce, Italian dressing) is available by the slice or full round. Authentic Italian cold cuts sliced fresh, house-made Italian sausage (hot or mild), imported Parmigiano Reggiano, and exceptional Wisconsin cheddars.

The full Italian grocery shopping experience makes this destination-worthy—browse imported goods, grab cannoli and Italian cookies. Virtual tours available. Holiday gift baskets shipped anywhere.

The Sausage Kitchen — Racine's three-generation tradition since 1958

Address: 1706 Rapids Drive, Racine, WI 53404
Phone: (262) 637-1089
Hours: Tuesday–Saturday 6:00 AM–2:00 PM; closed Sunday–Monday
Website: sausagekitchenracine.com

Voted Racine's #1 sub shop across three generations of family ownership. Custom subs come in multiple sizes with various bread choices. The Italian Sub (salami, prosciutto, capicola, provolone, mozzarella) and German Sub (German salami, imported ham, yachtwurst, brick, American) reflect Racine's diverse heritage. Breakfast sandwiches like the Steak, Egg & Cheese ($5.69) start early.

Historical Racine photos on walls create nostalgic atmosphere. Wisconsin cheese curds and onion rings round out the menu. Full deli with imported rare items. Catering platters available; delivery via DoorDash.

Lee's Deli — Racine's award-winner

Address: 2615 Washington Avenue, Racine, WI 53405
Phone: (262) 634-2373
Hours: Daily 9:00 AM–8:00 PM
Website: leesdeliracine.com

Winner of "Best of Racine County" 2024 by The Journal Times. The Godfather Sub has achieved legendary status, alongside Italian Beef and Steak Sub options. Extensive catering for parties and events. Delivers throughout Racine and into Kenosha (45-minute delivery time).

Morelli's Deli — Kenosha's neighborhood corner

Address: 7506 7th Avenue, Kenosha, WI 53143 (Corner of 75th St. & 7th Ave.)
Phone: (262) 654-9316
Hours: Open 7 days
Website: morellisdeli.com

The Italian Beef has achieved "local legend" status at this family-owned neighborhood spot where "everyone is treated like family." Meatball Bomber, BBQ Pulled Pork, and homemade Sloppy Joes offer variety. Meal deals with chips and drink run just $6–7. Uses Paielli's bread. Take-and-bake pizzas, homemade salsas and guacamole also available.

Hometown Meats Deli & Catering — Kenosha's butcher shop

Address: 4924 60th Street, Kenosha, WI 53144
Phone: (262) 652-6840
Hours: Monday–Saturday 8:00 AM–6:00 PM; Sunday 8:00 AM–5:00 PM (deli closes 1 hour before store)
Website: hometownmeatsdeli.com

Classic deli sandwich counter inside a premium butcher shop. Sub #5 (ham, salami, pepperoni, Colby cheese, provolone on Italian bread) represents their style. Eight different sub options available, plus fresh-sliced meats and homemade jerky (spicy and regular).

Party subs require 36-hour notice. Also offers pig roast catering and deer processing services—true Wisconsin butcher shop.

Baba's Standing Room Only — Kenosha's cheesesteak champion

Address: Kenosha, WI (near 75th St. & 7th Ave. area)
Website: babasro.com

Kenosha's top-rated cheesesteak destination. The Classic SRO Cheesesteak, Big Lou, Aloha, and Godfather variations satisfy serious cheesesteak cravings. Quaint outdoor patio seating; owner-operated with personal attention on every order.

Southern Milwaukee Suburbs: Oak Creek to Greenfield

GoldCoast Subs — Greenfield's signature spice

Address: 4263 W Layton Ave, Greenfield, WI 53221
Phone: (414) 817-1911
Hours: Tuesday–Saturday 10:30 AM–8:00 PM; closed Sunday–Monday
Website: goldcoastsubs.com

Over 30 years of family ownership have perfected the proprietary spice blend and oil that make GoldCoast subs "a class all their own." The signature Gold Dust (featuring Badger Ham) and Pentagon Club earn devoted followings. All subs include mayo, cheese, onion, tomato, lettuce, and that unique seasoning on fresh Italian bread.

Evolved from the legendary Suburpia sub shops. Subs run $10–14. Two-foot party subs (feeds 6–8) require 24-hour notice. Rustic small-town vibe despite suburban location. DoorDash delivery available.

Potbelly Sandwich Shop — Oak Creek

Address: 160 W Town Square Way, Suite 500, Oak Creek, WI 53154
Phone: (414) 563-5064
Hours: Daily 10:00 AM–10:00 PM
Website: potbelly.com

Near IKEA and Oak Creek Public Library for combined family outings. A Wreck (turkey, ham, roast beef, salami, Swiss) and Italian remain popular. Originals $5.99–$7.49, Bigs $7.99–$9.49. Outdoor seating, wheelchair accessible. Perks rewards program for savings.

Cousins Subs — South Milwaukee

Address: 2965 S Chicago Avenue, South Milwaukee, WI 53172
Phone: (414) 768-1111
Hours: Daily 9:30 AM–9:15 PM

Full menu including Philly Cheesesteak (chicken or steak with American cheese, sautéed peppers & onions) and Wisconsin Cheese Curds. Kids meals available.

Jersey Mike's — Oak Creek

Address: 8880 S Howell Avenue, Oak Creek, WI 53154
Phone: (414) 304-8601
Hours: Open 7 days, 10:00 AM–9:00 PM

Highly praised location with "top notch" food quality. Curbside pickup available.

Specialty Shops: Bánh Mì, Cuban, and Unique Concepts

For families seeking flavors beyond the traditional Italian sub.

Xankia — Downtown Milwaukee's only Vietnamese option

Address: 222 W Wells St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: (414) 817-0241
Website: xankiawi.com

Formerly Banh Mi Nhu Y, serving since 2010. The House Special Bánh Mì ($7) features pork pâté, vegetables, and Maggi sauce. Eight varieties available including grilled pork with jalapeños (customer favorite), steak, meatball, and tofu. Pho available daily except Monday ($8.50–$10).

Seating for 25–30, coffee bar with boba teas ($5.50). Voted best bánh mì by Milwaukee Magazine. Budget-friendly at $6–$14.

Additional Bánh Mì options

• Pho 4 U (Brookfield): 3835 N. 124th St (262-439-9149) — 6-inch classic bánh mì $6

• Pho Viet (Greenfield): 5475 S. 27th St (414-282-8852) — Pork meatloaf and pâté combo $7

• Pho Hai Tuyet (South Milwaukee area): 204 W. Layton Ave (414-231-3201) — Bánh Mì Thit Nuong $9, described by Milwaukee Record as "one of the top three sandwiches we've ever eaten"

• Hue Restaurant (Bay View): 2699 S. Kinnickinnic Ave — Five varieties including Lemongrass Beef, Chicken Katsu with unagi sauce, Char Xiu Pork

Cubanitas — Milwaukee's only Cuban restaurant

Address: 728 N Milwaukee St, Downtown Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone: (414) 291-3773
Website: getbianchini.com

Celebrating 20+ years as Milwaukee's first entirely Cuban restaurant. The signature Cuban sandwich features roasted pork, Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard-aioli pressed on bread flown in from the East Coast daily. "Change it and it's not a Cuban sandwich!" The Steak Sandwich includes thinly sliced sirloin with grilled onions and French fries ON the sandwich.

Sandwiches $10–14, entrées $12–25. Famous guacamole and plantain chips, mojitos, empanadas. Full catering available for private parties.

Wisconsin's Own: Understanding the Regional Chains

Cousins Subs — Born in Milwaukee, 1972

Founded by cousins Bill Specht and Jim Sheppard in Menomonee Falls, Cousins now operates 90+ locations across Wisconsin and Indiana. The signature fresh-baked bread recipe came from a local baker and hasn't changed in five decades. Official sponsors of the Milwaukee Bucks, Green Bay Packers, and Wisconsin Badgers.

Why families love them: Drive-thrus at most locations, consistent quality, kids meals with applesauce and juice box, Wisconsin cheese curds as sides. Party Boxes for catering require just 90-minute notice.

Signature items: Wisconsin Cheesesteak (USDA Choice steak with Wisconsin cheese), Italian Special (cappacolla ham, coteghino bologna, Genoa salami), Club Sub. Bread varieties include Garlic, Italian, and Parmesan-Asiago.

Notable Milwaukee-area locations include:

• Mitchell International Airport (Concourse C): 5300 S Howell Ave — Opens 4:30 AM for early flights

• Marquette University: 1612 W Wisconsin Ave — Popular with students

• Miller Park Way: 1150 Miller Park Way — Convenient to American Family Field

The Chocolate Factory — Wisconsin original since 1972

Eight locations across the metro, combining award-winning subs with Wisconsin ice cream. The Traveling Sundae Factory brings their ice cream bar to parties—perfect for birthday celebrations.

Suburpia — Living Milwaukee history

Just three locations remain of what was once a 20+ store empire. The exclusive use of Peter Sciortino Bakery sesame-seeded rolls and the tradition of eating from the bag (to catch the oil and seasonings) create a uniquely Milwaukee experience.

Quick Reference: Best Bets by Category

Best for combining lunch with dessert: The Chocolate Factory (any location) — subs + Wisconsin ice cream in one stop

Best cheesesteaks: Chubby's (Milwaukee), Baba's Standing Room Only (Kenosha)

Best historic Italian delis: Glorioso's (Brady Street), Tenuta's (Kenosha), Scardina Specialties (Riverwest)

Best for picky eaters: Jersey Mike's — watch your sub made fresh, customize everything

Best for dietary restrictions: Out & Out (Cedarburg) — gluten-free options available

Best for large group catering: Firehouse Subs (sub platters), The Chocolate Factory (Party Boxes + Traveling Sundae Factory), Marty's (up to 2,000 people)

Best value under $10: Suburpia, Cousins Subs, Xankia bánh mì

Best for Wisconsin nostalgia: Cousins Subs (founded locally), Suburpia (John Belushi connection), The Chocolate Factory (50+ years)

Best drive-thru options: Cousins Subs (most locations), Cousins Hartford

Best late-night options: Cheba Hut (until 2:00 AM weekends), Megawich (until 3:00 AM Friday–Saturday), Chubby's Cheesesteaks

Best adventure for cheese lovers: Bieri's Jackson Cheese & Deli — sample Wisconsin cheeses and build your own sandwich

Planning Your Sub Adventures

The beauty of greater Milwaukee's sub scene lies in its geographic diversity. North Shore families can build weekend traditions around The Chocolate Factory's lakefront Pewaukee location or Kurt Schulz Deli's Wednesday Sub Day. Downtown excursions pair naturally with Glorioso's on Brady Street or a quick Cuban sandwich from Cubanitas before a Bucks game.

For road trip provisions, the Mitchell Airport Cousins Subs opens at 4:30 AM—perfect for early flights. Summer lake days work beautifully with The Chocolate Factory's Oconomowoc or Pewaukee locations. And when you need to feed a crowd, Firehouse Subs and Marty's offer catering that scales from small gatherings to events serving 2,000.

Each of these shops represents someone's family tradition, their signature recipe, their piece of Milwaukee's culinary story. Whether it's Peter Sciortino's bread at Suburpia and Chubby's, four generations of Italian heritage at Tenuta's, or a secret spice blend perfected over 30 years at GoldCoast—the common thread is pride in the craft. That's what makes hunting down the perfect sub in greater Milwaukee more than just lunch. It's a taste of the community that made it.