Know the North Shore: Pete's Pops on Silver Spring

When the weather warms up and families start thinking about summer treats, there's one destination that consistently draws crowds to Whitefish Bay's bustling Silver Spring Drive: Pete's Pops. This beloved popsicle shop has become a cornerstone of North Shore summer traditions, offering handcrafted frozen treats that go far beyond your typical corner store fare.

Pete's Pops stands out in the crowded frozen treat landscape with its commitment to quality and creativity. Every pop is handcrafted using natural, super-fresh ingredients sourced locally whenever possible. With over 100 unique flavors in their repertoire and at least 12 rotating options available at any time, there's always something new to discover.

The flavor selection ranges from refreshing fruit combinations like Blueberry Basil Lemonade and Pineapple Jalapeño to indulgent treats like Coffee n Donuts and Key Lime Pie. Adventurous eaters can try the famous Avocado pop that originally inspired founder Pete Cooney, while traditionalists can enjoy classics like Fudgesicle and Strawberry Lemonade. The shop also caters to families with dietary restrictions, offering Top 8 Allergen Free Pops.

Planning Your Visit

Location: 334 E Silver Spring Drive, Whitefish Bay

Season: Pete's Pops Whitefish Bay typically reopens around April 15th each year, marking the unofficial start of popsicle season for many North Shore families.

Hours:

• Spring: Saturday and Sunday, noon to 8:00 pm

• Summer: Tuesday through Sunday, noon to 8:00 pm

The seasonal schedule aligns perfectly with peak demand for frozen treats, ensuring you'll find the freshest selection during the warmest days.

Beyond the Storefront

While the Whitefish Bay shop operates seasonally, Pete's Pops maintains a year-round presence through creative community engagement. Their annual "Golden Pop" promotion creates a Willy Wonka-style hunt for free pops, while weekly winter scavenger hunts keep the brand playfully relevant even when the physical shops are closed.

The company also offers comprehensive catering services for private events, bringing their unique treats to weddings, corporate gatherings, and school functions throughout the North Shore area.

Pete's Pops has created an environment where "people, and even dogs, come together." The welcoming atmosphere makes it a perfect stop for families with children of all ages, and the variety of flavors ensures even the pickiest eaters will find something they love.

The shop's integration into Silver Spring Drive's vibrant commercial corridor means you can easily combine a Pete's Pops visit with other family activities in downtown Whitefish Bay.

The Pete's Pops Story

From humble beginnings in founder Pete Cooney's East Side apartment kitchen to a multi-location Milwaukee phenomenon, Pete's Pops represents a true local success story. In May 2024, Ian Robinson acquired the business with a commitment to "keep the spirit of Pete's Pops alive," ensuring the brand's core values and unique offerings will continue delighting North Shore communities for years to come.

For North Shore families, Pete's Pops represents more than just a frozen treat – it's a sweet staple that enriches the local landscape one delicious pop at a time. Whether you're seeking a nostalgic classic or ready to try an adventurous new flavor, the Whitefish Bay location offers a moment of pure joy that has become synonymous with North Shore summers.

An Abundance of Flavors

One thing to know about the Pete’s Pop’s flavors: They’re ever-changing, and never boring. They even just announced a Cream City collaboration with the Milwaukee Bucks.

It’s wise to keep checking back to see what they are currently offering. But for the Pete’s Pops completists, here’s a full list of flavors they have offered at one time or another:

• Caramel Apple

• Fudgesicle

• Peanut Butter Cookie (2 variations)

• Pink Grapefruit (2 variations)

• Raspberry Lemonade (2 variations)

• Strawberry Lemonade

• Vanilla Malt

• Apricot Ginger

• Arnold Palmer

• Avocado (Pete's original inspiration flavor)

• Blackberry Limeade

• Blackberry Mint

• Blueberry Basil Lemonade

• Cantaloupe Lemongrass

• Coconut Lime (2 variations)

• Cranberry Orange

• Cucumber Lime

• Georgia Peach

• Honeydew Lime

• Lemon Poppy Seed

• Lime

• Mango Lassi

• Orange Dreamsicle

• Peaches 'N Cream

• Pineapple Jalapeño

• Plum Mint

• Rose Water Lemonade

• Salted Watermelon

• Sour Cherry

• Sweet Matcha Tea

• Thai Tea

• Banana Cream

• Birthday Cake

• Blueberry Pie

• Blue Moon

• Chai Latte

• Chocolate Covered Potato Chip

• Cinnamon Honey Cream

• Coffee 'N Donuts

• Coconut Cold Brew

• Cookies 'N Cream

• Golden Milk

• Horchata

• Hot Chocolate (2 variations)

• Key Lime Pie

• Peanut Butter & Jelly

• Pistachio

• Pumpkin Pie

• Root Beer Float

• Salted Butterscotch

• Wedding Cake

• Blueberry Toast Crunch

• Bomb Pop (Red, white & blue patriotic flavor)

• Gingerbread Cookie

• Hot Chocolate (Mexican variation)

• London Fog

• Pear Goat Cheese

• Rhubarb Buttermilk

• Sugar Snap Pea Lemonade

• Sweet Corn & Blackberry Swirl

• Tropical Hops

• Red Velvet

• Bomb Pop (Perfect for summer celebrations)

• Gingerbread Cookie (Holiday seasonal)

• Pumpkin Pie (Fall seasonal)

• Sneaky Pete's - Alcoholic slushies available at their Milwaukee Public Market pop-up location

With over 100 total flavors in their repertoire and continuous innovation, Pete's Pops ensures there's always something new to discover. Visit their Whitefish Bay location at 334 E Silver Spring Drive to see what's currently available!